All Clad vs Made In: Which Is Better?

Alyssa Corso Avatar

WRITTEN BY

PUBLISHED ON

Deciding on the right cookware can be a challenge. Knowing how quality cookware is a lasting investment, you need to weigh all your options before you make the purchase decision. With so many options available, finding the right brand can be challenging.

Among the top contenders are All-Clad, a household name with a legacy in stainless steel craftsmanship, and Made In, a direct-to-consumer brand that has rapidly gained a following for its quality and affordability.

Both brands offer high-performance cookware designed to elevate home cooking, but which one stands out?

This article closely examines the features, prices, and perks of the two brands to make the comparison easier so you can make the best decision for your needs and preferences.

Let’s begin!

Overview of All-Clad 

All-Clad is a well-known name in the world of cookware, setting the standard for quality and performance. It is often the brand that others are compared to in cooking publications.

The founder, John Ulam, discovered that by layering different metals—like stainless steel with aluminum or copper—he could create cookware that heats quickly and evenly.

Stainless steel became the cooking surface of choice because it doesn’t react with food, while aluminum and copper layers help with fast, consistent heating. Since 1971, All-Clad has expanded its original stainless steel line to include nonstick, ceramic, and hard-anodised options, along with bakeware and kitchen accessories. 

Made in the U.S., All-Clad remains a favorite for home cooks and chefs alike due to its lasting quality and American craftsmanship.

Overview of Made-In 

Made-In launched in 2017. But its roots go back nearly a century in the restaurant supply business, bringing a wealth of experience. Founded by Jake Kalick and Chip Malt, the brand’s mission is to bring high-quality, restaurant-grade cookware into home kitchens.

It started as a direct-to-consumer company, and today, its products are available on Amazon and Walmart. Known for its award-winning stainless steel cookware, Made-In also offers a range of materials, including nonstick, carbon steel, enameled cast iron, and copper. 

Crafted primarily in the U.S. and France, the brand partners with top artisans to ensure that every piece is made to last and is easy for home cooks to use.

If you are starting from scratch, you must go through a comprehensive comparison of the two brands. 

Below, I’ve shared some insightful info about different aspects of both brands. Read, review, and invest carefully!

All-Clad Products & Features

All-Clad is a cookware veteran with several cookware collections. Each collection has unique materials, designs, construction, and salient features. Here is a quick glance at its most popular collections:

Copper Core

Features

Every piece of this line is hand-crafted in the US and features a 5-layer construction for top-notch performance. 

  • Made with five layers: stainless steel, aluminum, and a copper core from the base to the sides. This construction spreads heat quickly and evenly for precise cooking.
  • The cooking surface is crafted from 18/10 stainless steel, which won’t react with food and is easy to keep clean.
  • Handles are solid stainless steel, designed to stay cool on the stove and offer a comfortable grip.
  • The cookware is held together with strong, corrosion-resistant rivets, making each piece durable and long-lasting.

The Copper Core collection can be used on different stoves, including induction. They are oven-safe, up toupto 600°F. I’d recommend hand-washing only to maintain the copper shining. An occasional polish keeps your pieces looking sharp and is set to act anytime!

Popular Products & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces10″ Fry Pan$279.95
3-Quart Saucepan$199.95
12″ Fry PanSimilar price range
2-Quart SaucepanSimilar price range
Cookware Sets5-Piece SetApprox. $799.95
14-Piece SetUp to $2,199.95


TriPly (D3)

This is the best-seller of All-Clad’s collection due to its classic design and versatile usage. 

  • Tri-ply construction with stainless steel at both ends and aluminum or copper in the middle. This construction ensures even heat distribution.
  • An 18/10 stainless steel cooking surface that doesn’t react with food and is easy to clean.
  • Long handles are made from solid stainless steel and designed for comfort and to stay cool on the stove.
  • A high-polished mirror finish on the outside.

The D3 collection is compatible with gas, electric, and induction stovetops, making it quite versatile. This range is known for its performance and durability. These factors appeal to home cooks and professionals alike, making them a best-selling range of the entire All-Clad collection.

Popular Products & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces8.5-inch SkilletApproximately $89.99
10.5-inch SkilletAround $99.99
3-quart Sauté Pan with Lid$250
3-quart Saucepan with LidAbout $119.99
6-quart Stockpot with LidTypically $335
Cookware Sets5-piece Cookware SetRegularly $535, often $399.9

D5

The D5 collection, with its 5-ply bonded construction, is one of its kind. The steel core makes heat transfer slower but more evenly than other ranges.

  • A special 5-ply design runs throughout the pan, made of layers of stainless steel and aluminum.
  • The inside is polished 18/10 stainless steel that doesn’t react with food.
  • The riveted handles stay cool, and the pans have flared rims for easy pouring.
  • The outside has a shiny, brushed stainless steel finish that doesn’t show fingerprints.
  • It also features a high-polished mirror finish on the exterior.

This multi-layer design stops warping and helps heat spread evenly. The frying pans have three layers of PFOA-free nonstick coating, which makes food slide off easily and cleanup simple. While they are safe for the oven, it’s best not to wash them in the dishwasher since that could damage the steel.

Popular Products & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces10-inch Fry PanApproximately $129.99
12-inch Fry PanAround $169.99
3-Quart Saucepan with LidAbout $159.99
6-Quart Stockpot with LidPriced at $399.99
3-Quart Sauté PanTypically $249.99
2-Quart SaucepanApproximately $119.99
Cookware Sets5-Piece SetAbout $599.99
10-Piece SetAround $999.99

Graphite Core (G5)

This is the latest and fastest-heating range by All-Clad. The key factor behind its success is a graphite disc at the bottom, surrounded by an aluminum core. This design allows consistent heating from the center to the edges, ensuring even cooking.

  • Five layers of materials ensure even heating.
  • The cooking surface is made of 18/10 stainless steel, which is easy to clean and won’t react with food.
  • The long handles are made from solid stainless steel and are designed for comfort and staying cool while cooking.
  • A graphite core offers quick and even heating, providing the benefits of a five-layer pan while being lighter like a three-layer pan.

The lightweight design makes it easier to toss and flip the food. The exclusive range is worth every penny!

Products & Price Ranges

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces8” Frying Pan$109.95
10″ Fry Pan$129.95
3 Qt Sauté Pan$169.95
2 Qt Saucepan$159.95
5 Qt Dutch Oven$249.95
Cookware Sets10-Piece Set (includes various pans and lids)$1,299.95
8-Piece Set$899.95

All-Clad: Warranty & Refund Policy

All of the listed All-Clad collections have a limited lifetime warranty. This warranty covers any defects in materials and craftsmanship when used typically. It gives buyers confidence that their cookware is well-made.

For returns, the rules can differ based on the store. Many retailers allow returns within 30 to 45 days. To get a full refund, the items usually need to be unused or only gently used, and they should be in their original packaging.

Made-In Products & Features

Since its launch, Made-In has quickly proven that it is here to stay. Big-shot celebrities like Grant Achatz and Tom Colicchio endorse the brand for its quality. Check out its collections below:

Non-Stick Collection

The quality of this cookware set is outstanding. The pots and pans have a nice weight, indicating they are not a cheap purchase.

  • The handles feel comfortable in your grip, and the cookware heats up evenly and cleans easily.
  • It features a high-performance Teflon layer that prevents sticking.
  • The clad construction keeps the pots and pans in excellent shape.
  • It works on all stovetops and is oven-safe up to 500 degrees.

This set excels in cooking. It offers exceptional heat distribution, even on an electric stove. Plus, the nonstick surface makes cleanup a breeze. There may be minor wear over time, but it doesn’t impact the cooking ability.

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces8-inch Frying Pan$119
10-inch Frying Pan$129
12-inch Frying Pan$149
2-quart Saucepan$159
3-quart Saucier$179
5-quart Saucier$199
3.5-quart Saute Pan$179
8-quart Stock Pot$259
Cookware Sets3-Piece Frying Pan Set$349
10-Piece Cookware Set$599
12-Piece Cookware Set$749

Stainless Steel Collection

This range by Made-In is known for its quality design, durability, and versatility. They focused their energy on producing versatile pans. You won’t find gimmicky or redundant pieces here.

  • The 5-ply construction of stainless steel and aluminum provides even heating and good heat retention
  • The non-reactive 18/10 stainless steel interior prevents food flavor changes and is easy to clean
  • Compatible with all stovetops, including induction
  • Handles stay cool and are shaped for a comfortable grip
  • Safe for oven use up to 800°F; dishwasher-safe (hand washing recommended to keep its shine)

This collection aims to provide professional-level cookware that is accessible for home use. It has a durable construction lasts for years and meets everyday cooking needs.

Product Types & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces10″ Fry Pan$119
12″ Fry Pan$139
2-Quart Saucepan$129
3-Quart Sauté Pan$189
8-Quart Stock Pot$249
Cookware Sets3-Piece Set$269
6-Piece Set$529
10-Piece Set$779
13-Piece Set$1,049

Copper

Copper cookware is becoming less common in today’s kitchens. While you might have seen beautiful images of copper production in Villedieu-les-Poêles, France, or spotted it in specialty cookware shops, chances are you haven’t used it for cooking. The Made-In copper collection reintroduces this material, encouraging its users to awaken the chef in them!

  • A copper core surrounded by stainless steel offers excellent heat conductivity and precise temperature control.
  • Copper ensures even heat distribution, perfect for delicate sauces and dishes.
  • Oven-safe up to 800°F, suitable for various cooking methods.
  • The stainless steel interior is easy to clean and resists food reactions. 

With its polished copper look, this cookware adds a professional touch to any kitchen. When cared for properly, it can last for years without asking for occasional fixtures.

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces9” Frying Pan479
10” Frying Pan$89
12” Frying Pan$109
12” Steel Wok$129
Cookware SetsCarbon Sous Set
(Includes a 12″ Frying Pan, 12″ Wok, and a Roasting Pan.)
$339

Enameled Cast Iron

This slick and low-maintenance range by Made-In is indeed a spectacular launch. Its excellent heat retention and superior quality make it stand out among others.

  • Made from quality cast iron, which holds and distributes heat evenly. It is perfect for searing, browning, and steady cooking.
  • Each piece is pre-seasoned, creating a naturally nonstick surface that improves with use and makes food release easier.
  • Works on all stovetops, including induction, and can go from stovetop to oven, ideal for baking, roasting, and braising.
  • Features ergonomic handles for comfortable lifting and moving, even with heavier dishes.
  • Built to withstand high heat and frequent use, ensuring durability and a long lifespan in any kitchen.

Always preheat your cast-iron cookware for about five to six minutes before use. If you skip this step, food may stick, regardless of the interior finish. Don’t forget to use butter or oil, as omitting them can lead to sticking issues.

Product Types & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrices
Individual Pieces10.5-Inch Skillet$99
6-Quart Dutch Oven$249
3.5-Quart Round Dutch Oven$159
12-Inch Skillet$129
Cookware Sets5-Piece Set$299
3-Piece Set$179

Carbon Steel

Carbon steel is a combination of carbon and iron. This collection is known for its responsive heat retention and natural non-stick surface. 

  • Lighter than cast iron but just as sturdy, carbon steel heats up fast for quick, efficient cooking
  • With seasoning, it forms a natural nonstick layer over time, which is great for low-fat cooking
  • Safe for high-heat use on any stovetop, including induction and ovens
  • Designed for various cooking methods like sautéing, roasting, and baking
  • Though not dishwasher-safe, it is easy to clean, and seasoning keeps enhancing the nonstick surface and durability

This collection is the ultimate favorite of those who wish to get traditional cookware. The manageable pans and multiple options make it a popular choice.

Product Types & Prices

Product TypeDescriptionPrice
Individual Pieces8”-12” Fry Pans$79 – $99
12” Steel Wok$99
Steel Griddle$99
Roasting Pan$129
Cookware Sets10″ Fry Pan & 12″ Griddle$179
Wok, 10″ & 12″ Fry Pans, Roaster$297

Made-In: Warranty & Refund Policy

Made-In offers a lifetime warranty on their cookware. This warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship under normal use. You can contact their customer service for assistance if you find a defect.

As for returns, Made-In provides a 30-day return window. Items must be unused and in their original packaging to qualify for a refund. If you are unsatisfied with your purchase, initiate the return within this timeframe to get your money back. For detailed information, you can visit their official website.

Which Is Better?

The debate of All-Clad vs. Made-In is common in culinary circles. It is understood that picking the right tools and properly using cookware is essential for flavorful outcomes. 

Here is a concise table comparing All-Clad and Made-In cookware based on various factors, including specific instances where one brand may have an advantage over the other:

FeatureAll-CladMade-In
ReputationWell-respected since the 1970s. It has established itself as an industry leader.Innovative startup since 2016; disrupts market by offering direct-to-consumer pricing.
Product OfferingsMultiple collections with unique features.Five types of cookware (5-ply stainless steel, carbon steel, non-stick, copper, enameled cast iron), but only one version each.
Construction and MaterialsOffers 2-ply to 5-ply construction with various cores, including carbon steel.5-ply construction with triple-layer aluminum core; carbon steel offered.
DesignBrushed, polished, or copper exteriors; U-shaped handles.Chic brushed exterior; flat handles and larger lid grips for ease.
Heat Test ResultsHeats evenly; slower heat retention than Made-In.Heats up slightly faster and retains heat longer.
Cooking PerformanceExcellent cooking results; well-cooked meats.Similar cooking performance; heats faster, but results are comparable
Manufacturing LocationsMade in Canonsburg, PA, using U.S. materials.Partners with family-owned businesses in the U.S., France, and Italy.
Oven-Safe TemperaturesUp to 600°F for stainless steel; 500°F for non-stick.Up to 800°F for stainless steel; and 1200°F for carbon steel.
Cooktop CompatibilityCompatible with all except the Essentials collection.Compatible with all cooktops, including induction.
PriceGenerally more expensive due to brand prestige.More affordable; sells directly to consumers to cut costs.

Specific advantages include All-Clad’s diverse product offerings and a long-standing reputation for quality. In contrast, Made-In stands out with better heat retention and higher oven-safe temperatures, making it suitable for high-heat cooking. Moreover, Made-In’s direct-to-consumer model offers significant savings compared to All-Clad’s retail prices.

Insider’s Insight

When wondering about All-Clad vs. Made-In, know that each brand has high-quality products for home cooking. If you want timeless craftsmanship and a legacy that dates back decades, All-Clad might be your best choice. But if you crave innovation without breaking the bank, consider investing in Made-In pieces that challenge the status quo. Each brand has its strengths, catering to different cooking styles and budgets.

The final choice boils down to what feels right in your kitchen!

*Note: The prices mentioned in this article may vary according to retailer policies and ongoing discounts.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *